Choosing the right diesel type isn’t just about fuel—it’s about your fleet’s performance, efficiency, and reliability. For fleets, understanding the differences between #1 and #2 diesel can significantly impact operational costs and vehicle longevity. 

In this guide, we will break down these two types of diesel fuel to help you make informed decisions that align with your fleet’s needs.

What is #1 Diesel?

#1 diesel, often called winter diesel, is formulated specifically for cold-weather performance.¹ Its unique properties include a lower viscosity, which allows it to flow easily even in freezing temperatures. This thinner consistency helps reduce the risk of gelling in the engine, a common issue in colder climates. 

In addition to its cold-weather advantages, #1 diesel ignites faster and burns cleaner, making it a reliable choice for maintaining vehicle performance during harsh winters. However, it comes with a slightly lower energy output, which can impact fuel efficiency.²

For fleets operating in areas prone to severe winters, #1 diesel is often the best choice to ensure uninterrupted operations.

What is #2 Diesel?

#2 diesel is the industry standard for most fleet vehicles and is best suited for regular driving conditions.³ Its higher energy content per gallon provides superior fuel efficiency, making it the preferred option for maximizing mileage during everyday operations. 

This efficiency translates to significant cost savings over time, especially for fleets covering long distances. While it’s ideal for moderate weather, #2 diesel can present challenges in extreme cold, as it is prone to gelling.

To counteract this, many fleet managers add anti-gel additives during winter months, ensuring fuel flows smoothly through the engine. Overall, #2 diesel, like renewable diesel, is the backbone of fuel efficiency for fleets across the United States.

Cold-Weather Performance vs Efficiency

The decision between diesel 1 vs diesel 2 often hinges on balancing cold-weather reliability and fuel economy. Here are some of the things you must consider:

1. Cold-Weather Reliability: #1 diesel reigns supreme in freezing temperatures, thanks to its resistance to gelling. For fleets operating in northern regions or during winter months, it’s often a no-brainer.
2. Fuel Economy: Diesel 1 vs diesel 2 shows a clear difference in fuel economy. #2 diesel outshines with its higher energy content, making it more efficient for long hauls and day-to-day operations.
3. Blended Options: Many fleets opt for a blend of #1 and #2 diesel during transitional seasons to strike a balance between efficiency and cold-weather performance.

Pros and Cons of #1 Diesel for Fleets

When winter conditions hit hard, #1 diesel becomes a reliable ally for fleet managers looking to avoid operational hiccups. However, its advantages in cold-weather performance come with trade-offs in efficiency and cost, making it essential to weigh the pros and cons carefully.

Pros:

• Exceptional cold-weather performance
• Reduced risk of gelling in extreme conditions
• Cleaner combustion, benefiting the diesel engine in low temperatures

Cons:

• Lower fuel efficiency
• Higher cost per gallon compared to #2 diesel
• Less energy output per unit, impacting mileage

Pros and Cons of #2 Diesel for Fleets

#2 diesel stands out as the go-to choice for everyday fleet operations, offering efficiency and cost savings in moderate conditions. However, its performance can falter in freezing temperatures, requiring extra precautions to keep your fleet running smoothly.

Pros:

• Higher fuel efficiency and mileage
• Cost-effective for standard driving conditions
• Widely available across the United States

Cons:

• Susceptible to gelling in freezing temperatures
• Requires fuel additives for winter use
• Not ideal for extreme weather or OTR routes in colder climates

When to Use #1 vs #2 Diesel in Your Fleet

Knowing when to use diesel fuel 1 vs 2 is crucial for fleet efficiency:

• Seasonal Use: Opt for #1 diesel in winter or in areas prone to severe cold. Switch back to #2 diesel during warmer months to maximize efficiency.
• Regional Considerations: Fleets operating in colder northern states should prioritize #1 diesel or a winterized blend. In southern regions, #2 diesel is more than sufficient year-round.
• Fleet Size and Budget: Large fleets might benefit from a mix-and-match approach, adjusting based on weather forecasts and routes to optimize costs.

Proactive fuel management, including seasonal transitions and monitoring the weight of diesel fuel, ensures your fleet stays operational regardless of conditions.

How AtoB Supports Fuel Management for Fleets

Navigating the complexities of diesel #2 vs #1 is easier with AtoB’s fleet fuel cards. Designed to simplify fuel management, AtoB helps you maximize cost efficiency and streamline operations:

1. Fleet Fuel Card with Discounts: Save on every gallon with AtoB’s competitive pricing structure and fleet fuel card with discounts.
2. Real-Time Tracking: Monitor fuel usage and optimize routes with ease.
3. Transparent Pricing: Avoid hidden fees and get clear insights into your fleet’s fuel expenses.
4. Comprehensive Support: AtoB’s solutions integrate seamlessly with your fuel system components and fleet operations, ensuring compliance and efficiency.

Explore AtoB’s fuel discount card and over-the-road solutions to take control of your fleet’s fuel management today.

Choosing between #1 and #2 diesel depends on your fleet’s specific needs, seasonal demands, and cost considerations. While #1 diesel offers unbeatable performance in the cold, #2 diesel remains the backbone of efficiency for most fleets. By understanding the differences and planning accordingly, fleet managers can keep operations smooth and budgets intact.

AtoB makes it easier. From discounts to real-time fuel tracking and analyzing fleet performance, AtoB’s fleet fuel cards empower you to manage fuel expenses effectively. Discover how AtoB can help you optimize fuel costs and keep your fleet moving efficiently.

‍

Sources:

‍

Nationwide Fuels. Guide to Diesel Blends for Summer & Winter. https://www.nationwidefuels.co.uk/oil-guides/guide-diesel-blends-summer-winter/

‍

Anytime Fuel Pros. On-Road Diesel vs. Off-Road Diesel. https://www.anytimefuelpros.com/diesel-1-and-diesel-2/

‍

Ricochet Fuel Distributors. Diesel vs. Gasoline: Which Engine Types is Best for Your Needs?. https://www.ricochetfuel.com/blog/diesel-vs-gasoline-which-engine-types-is-best-for-your-needs/

‍